Grey composite deck wrapping around a lawn with an outdoor sofa

Trex vs Timber Decking: Which Is Better for Your Garden?

Most people who call us start with the same question. Should we go for timber or composite? Timber is cheaper on day one. Trex costs more to buy but far less to look after. Here is how the two compare, based on more than 20 years of building decks across Hertfordshire and the surrounding counties.

The short answer

If you want the lowest upfront price and you don’t mind yearly upkeep, timber will do the job. If you want a deck that still looks good in 20 years with little more than a wash, Trex is the better buy.

Cost

Treated softwood is the cheapest decking you can buy. Hardwood costs more, and Trex costs more again at the start. The gap closes over time, though. Timber needs cleaning and re-treating every year or two, and the boards often need replacing after 10 to 15 years. Trex needs none of that, so the running costs over the life of the deck are much lower.

How long each one lasts

A treated softwood deck usually lasts around 10 to 15 years if you look after it, and less if you don’t. Trex boards come with a 25 or 50 year limited residential warranty, depending on the range, plus a fade and stain warranty of the same length. Our guide on how long Trex decking lasts goes into more detail.

Maintenance

Timber needs regular sweeping, a scrub or jet wash, sanding where it gets rough, and a fresh coat of oil, stain or preservative every year or two. In shady corners it can turn green and slippery.

Trex only needs a sweep and a wash with warm soapy water a couple of times a year. There is no sanding, staining or painting. The boards resist mould, stains and scratches, and they won’t rot or splinter, which is good news for bare feet, children and pets.

Timber deck with rotten boards replaced by new ones

Looks

Timber has a natural grain, but it fades to a silvery grey unless you keep treating it. Modern Trex boards have a realistic wood grain in colours from pale grey to rich brown, and they hold their colour. The best way to judge is in person, so order free Trex samples and put them next to your patio or house.

Weathered grey timber deck boards

The environment

Trex boards are made with up to 95% recycled material, mainly reclaimed sawdust and plastic film that would otherwise go to waste. Timber is a renewable material if it is responsibly sourced, so look for FSC or PEFC certification. It does need replacing more often, though.

Two-tier grey composite deck with a curved edge, sofa and bistro set

Don’t forget the frame

Whatever boards you choose, the frame underneath decides how long your deck lasts. We use UC4 treated timber joists, seal every cut end, cover the joists with Trex Protect tape and leave plenty of airflow underneath. For damp spots, roof terraces and pool surrounds we can build on aluminium or HDPE framing instead.

Which should you choose?

  • Choose timber if budget is the main concern and you’re happy to maintain it every year.
  • Choose Trex if you want a low-maintenance deck that lasts for decades, keeps its colour and adds value to your home.

We install both, but we recommend Trex for most gardens. If you are weighing up other composite brands, read our Trex vs Millboard comparison, or browse the Trex decking range to see the colours.

We cover Hitchin, Letchworth, Stevenage, St Albans and the wider area. See our recent decking projects, find out more about our Trex decking installation service, or get in touch for a free quote. You can also call us on 01462 415521.

Common questions

Yes, at the start. Trex boards cost more to buy than treated softwood. Because Trex needs no staining, sanding or replacement boards, it often works out cheaper over the life of the deck.

Like any decking, darker boards get warmer in strong sun. Trex Transcend Lineage and the Enhance colour Tide Pool use Trex’s SunComfortable technology to stay cooler underfoot.

Sometimes. The frame has to be sound and the joists spaced to suit Trex boards. We check the frame at the survey and tell you whether it can be reused.

Ready to plan your Trex deck?

We design and install Trex decking across Hitchin, Letchworth, Stevenage, St Albans and the surrounding counties. Book a free site visit and quote, or see the boards for yourself first.

Prefer to talk? Call us on 01462 415521, every day from 8am to 6pm.

Similar Posts